Re: Duelling - Throw down the gauntlet and have at it.
Posted by Guest on 2004/10/5 12:35:58
Giving this more thought. Still a nice idea. But it needs work. Suggests on weapons of choice?
Also I think judging needs to expand. Though we may say we are impartial, we all have tastes and a challenge pic that fits our taste better than the other, even if it is of lesser quality, might get the vote. Also there's the name thing, some people have a name that's gonna tug on the judge's brainpan more so than others.
I think at a minimum we need 3 judges and at most 5 (2 and 4 being out cuz of the possibility of a tie).
Also I think judging needs to expand. Though we may say we are impartial, we all have tastes and a challenge pic that fits our taste better than the other, even if it is of lesser quality, might get the vote. Also there's the name thing, some people have a name that's gonna tug on the judge's brainpan more so than others.
I think at a minimum we need 3 judges and at most 5 (2 and 4 being out cuz of the possibility of a tie).
This Post was from: http://heromorph.com/heromorph2/newbb/viewtopic.php?forum=16&topic_id=520&post_id=3847