Re: The Put Up!
Posted by bhm1954 on 2008/7/7 8:28:29
I also put a lot of thought into this because this is really close. Both manips are amazing. I really liked Bio's manip right away, it had instantly reconizable characters and it looked cool. On the other hand, if not for the title Hawk's manip it would have taken a while to figure out who these characters were. (I have seen Yu-gi-oh GX with my son and grandkids so I do know the show.)
Techniclly they are both very good but I give the edge to Hawk. As for the layout, I agree that Hawks does seem to show more of a theme, it has more complexity than Bio's.
This is so close that I would like to call it a tie, but I won't.
My vote goes to Hawk.
This Post was from: http://heromorph.com/heromorph2/newbb/viewtopic.php?forum=16&topic_id=2138&post_id=25791