Re: Winterhawk Vs. Black Alchemy Judging results

Posted by Billy on 2004/10/11 16:36:38

oh boy....this is gonna be tough....you both are VERY talented and are also my good buds, but i gotta do what i gotta do.....


ok.(deep breath)

first off...

WINTERHAWK: i think your sue is awesome...the seams look good to me, good shading, excellent wrinkles.

BLACK ALCHEMY: your jesse looks outstanding...i love her costume...i don't know about her that much, so i'm assuming you got the costume dead on...your costume work is amazing, wrinkles r in place,shading looks good...has a fabric look to it.

point to:BA

BLACK ALCHEMY: your lady pendragon looks incredible...i have to disagree with everyone that complained about te gold...i like it...it stands out...which although i've never seen gold armor before, but i'm sure its suppose too...i especailly like how you used your fine eye for detail, and added the pendant...nice touch.

WINTERHAWK: you went the extra mile and animated sue...I thought that was not only sneaky, but extremely creative...you did an excellent job with the smoothness of your animation...top notch work...

point:WINTERHAWK

now here is the hard part...i like them all so much...and you both are so talented...NOT to mention there are a lot of similarities in your work...if it weren't for the animation, i'd call this a tie...but i think that the .gif gives WH the slight advantage...

so, winner of my vote by the slightest margin...WINTERHAWK....