| Re: Billy and Winterhawk Challenge Judging |
Subject: Re: Billy and Winterhawk Challenge Judging
by Guest on 2004/10/23 15:25:19
Ok, chiming in with my judgment.
Billy's submission:
I think he chose a real interesting set-up for his submission in terms of character composition. Nicely done. It makes me think that Hatter somehow escaped but the crazy bastard still has time for tea, even during a heated escape attempt. :)
You successfully incorporated all of the base images into an interesting and effective collage.
A few tiny flaws like the edges on the Hatter's collar but nothing serious.
Good work!
Winterhawk's submission:
Very neat setup! Sequential pages are not easy to do and good sequentials are even harder to do!
You safely and successfully incorporated all the base images but also managed to tell a short story. Very good work. The integration of the base images were done very nicely. Be proud. :)
Judgment: I'd have to give a very close edge win to Winterhawk, only because he tackled a sequential page, which is slightly harder to do than a pinup image.
Good work, both of you!
|
|
